Friday, October 24, 2008

My Findings

I have to admit that while I do have a much better understanding of why people participate in beauty pageants after doing the research that I have done for this blog, I still do not completely agree with everything they stand for. I do think that the intentions behind pageants are good and are very important. The scholarship opportunities offered through these organizations are great and teaching young women to be well rounded in talent and intelligence is also positive. However, the way that pageants are set up is contradictory to these values. The higher level pageants like Miss America give young girls another size zero perfect model to look up to and in a society where girls are taught to hate their bodies at such a young age, this is the last thing that we need. Pageants for girls as young as two might be a fun outlet if the girls do not focus on doing whatever it takes to win and try to have fun. However, for a lot of girls this is not the case. Someone has to win and make it to the USA and World pageants and this means that not all of the girls are taking pageants lightly. Telling a girl of two years old that in order to be a winner she has to be not only pretty but the prettiest is not the way to instill confidence in a child. True, the aesthetics of a contestant might be only 30% of her total value in the competition, but it is an important 30%. I would like to see pageant officials make changes in the way they judge or how they hold to competition in order to show women and young girls alike that beauty is not the most important thing and that perfection is unattainable. I don’t know if this is possible but it would be interesting to see an effort put in to this.

2 comments:

Meg said...

I found it interesting to read about the ways that the media sheds a bad light on beauty pageants. At least for me, it seems like I have accepted what is shown in movies like Miss Congeniality to be what a beauty pageant is really like. It’s almost embarrassing that I have allowed myself to believe the image that the media wants me to.
I think that the idea you posed about changing the way that the judging is done is a valid one. Aren’t the women in the beauty pageant looking for the opinion of those viewing them? If this were the case then perhaps if those viewing them were less harsh then it would influence the pageant culture for the better.
Your entry about the “Smart Beauties” made me think about an entry I wrote for my blog about the Miss Tattoo pageant. Both of these seem like efforts to break free of the stereotypes that pageants have come to be known by. The Miss Tattoo website highlights the pageant by saying:
“Unlike many traditional pageants, ours is not in pursuit of the most beautiful girl, but rather a quest for tattooed women who carry themselves proudly and are making a statement of individuality by decorating their bodies with ink. We want to show your colors to the world, and by doing so help to break the social taboos of the past.”


Source:
2008 Miss Tattoo. Electronic document,
http://misstattoousa.com, accessed November 20.

Meg said...

And... Great job Liz!